Top Bar Hives are a beehive design that’s been gaining popularity among beekeepers looking for a simpler, more natural approach to keeping bees. This hive design is centuries old, originating from traditional beekeeping methods in places like Greece and Africa. It’s characterized by its horizontal layout and the absence of frames, which differentiates it from the more conventional Langstroth hives.
One of the first things you’ll notice about a Top Bar Hive is its simplicity. The hive consists of a long box with wooden bars laid across the top. These bars act as the foundation for the bees to build their comb. Unlike the Langstroth hive, which uses pre-made frames and often requires precise measurements and fittings, Top Bar Hives allow the bees to construct their comb in a more natural way. This can be beneficial for the health of the bee colony and can make the hive easier for beginners to manage.
Why might you choose a Top Bar Hive? Well, for one, they’re generally less expensive to build or purchase compared to Langstroth hives. Since you’re not buying frames and foundation, the startup cost can be much lower. Plus, the horizontal design means that the hive is often more accessible. You don’t have to lift heavy boxes to check on your bees, making it a good option for those with physical limitations or anyone looking for an easier way to manage their hive.
In addition, Top Bar Hives promote more sustainable beekeeping practices. Because you’re allowing bees to build their comb naturally, there’s less interference with their natural processes. This can lead to healthier bees and more robust hives over time. Plus, the design allows for better ventilation, which can be crucial in warm climates.
So, if you’re interested in beekeeping but are put off by the complexities and costs of traditional hives, a Top Bar Hive might be just the thing for you. It’s a straightforward, cost-effective, and bee-friendly way to get started in this fascinating hobby.
Comparing Top Bar Hives and Langstroth Hives
Top Bar Hives and Langstroth Hives are the two most popular choices for beekeeping, but they come with their own set of unique characteristics and management techniques. Understanding these differences can help you decide which hive might be best for you.
One of the main differences is the hive design. Top Bar Hives are horizontally oriented with bars across the top, allowing bees to build comb naturally. Langstroth hives, on the other hand, are vertically oriented and built with frames inside stacked boxes. This modular design makes it easier to expand the hive as the colony grows, but it does require more initial setup and ongoing manipulation of the frames.
When it comes to bee management, the techniques for handling the bees and inspecting the hive differ significantly. In a Top Bar Hive, you’ll be lifting individual bars to check the comb and bees, which some find to be a more gentle and natural approach. Langstroth hives require lifting heavy boxes to access different levels, which can be physically demanding and more intrusive to the bees.
As for the pros and cons, Top Bar Hives are often praised for their simplicity and cost-effectiveness. They usually require less maintenance and fewer materials, making them a good choice for hobbyists and those new to beekeeping. Langstroth hives, though more complex and expensive, generally allow for higher honey yields because they support a larger colony and more efficient storage of honey.
There are specific scenarios where one hive type might be preferred over the other. For instance, if honey production is your primary goal, a Langstroth hive might be more suitable due to its higher capacity. However, if you’re interested in natural beekeeping practices and a simpler, more hands-off approach, a Top Bar Hive might be the better choice.
In summary, the decision between a Top Bar Hive and a Langstroth hive largely comes down to your goals and preferences as a beekeeper. Each has its own set of advantages and potential drawbacks, so it’s all about finding the right fit for your needs and style of beekeeping.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Top Bar Hives
Top Bar Hives offer several advantages that make them appealing to many beekeepers. One major benefit is their simplicity. The straightforward design means there’s less equipment and fewer complications, making it easier for beginners to get started. You don’t need to invest in additional gear like extractors, and you won’t have to worry about precise measurements and fittings.
Another big advantage is the lower cost. Because you aren’t purchasing complex components like frames and supers, you’ll spend less money initially. This is great if you’re on a budget or just testing the waters of beekeeping.
Natural beekeeping practices are another significant advantage. Since you’re letting bees build their own comb, they can manage their colony in a more natural way. This often results in healthier hives with fewer issues related to diseases and pests. Additionally, the horizontal structure can offer better air flow, helping maintain optimal hive conditions, particularly in warmer climates.
However, Top Bar Hives aren’t without their disadvantages. One drawback is the lower honey yield. Compared to Langstroth hives, the amount of honey you’ll harvest from a Top Bar Hive is typically less because the hive supports smaller colonies. This can be a downside if honey production is your main objective.
Cold climates can present challenges as well. The horizontal design tends to be less efficient at retaining heat, which can be problematic in areas with harsh winters. Extra insulation might be needed to keep the bees comfortable.
Impact on bee health and behavior can be both an advantage and a disadvantage. While the natural comb building is generally good for the bees, the irregular shape of the combs can make hive inspections and management a bit trickier. You’ll need to be careful when handling the combs to avoid breaking them.
Feedback from experienced beekeepers often includes mixed reviews. Some swear by the simplicity and natural benefits of Top Bar Hives, while others point out the limitations in honey production and the challenges in colder climates. It comes down to your priorities and what you’re hoping to get out of your beekeeping experience.
Harvesting Honey from a Top Bar Hive
Harvesting honey from a Top Bar Hive can be a straightforward and rewarding process. The steps you’ll follow ensure that both you and the bees experience minimal stress and disruption.
First, gather your tools. You’ll need a bee suit for protection, a hive tool for prying apart the bars, a smoker to calm the bees, and containers to hold the honeycomb. Unlike Langstroth hives, you won’t need an extractor or extra equipment to separate the honey from the comb.
Start by gently smoking the hive entrance. This calms the bees and makes them less likely to sting. Once the bees are calm, open the hive and carefully lift one of the top bars. Inspect the comb to make sure it’s filled with capped honey. When the comb is ripe for harvesting, the cells will be sealed with a thin layer of wax.
Remove the bar holding the comb filled with honey. Move slowly to avoid jolting the bees. Brush away any bees from the comb into the hive to ensure they remain safe. After removing the comb, you can cut it free from the bar and place it in your container.
Once you’ve harvested the desired amount of honey, replace the top bar and close the hive. This minimizes the time the hive is open, protecting the colony from potential threats like robbers or weather changes.
Processing the honeycomb is simple. Crush the comb in a clean container to release the honey, then strain it through a fine mesh or cheesecloth to remove wax bits and impurities. Store the honey in airtight jars, and you’re good to go!
Remember, harvesting from a Top Bar Hive is all about balance. While you want to enjoy the fruits of your labor, it’s crucial to leave enough honey for the bees, especially heading into winter. Typically, leaving about one-third of the honey ensures that the bees have enough food supplies.
This method emphasizes sustainable beekeeping practices. By taking just enough honey and leaving plenty for the colony, you support the health and longevity of your hive. Plus, there’s something incredibly satisfying about enjoying honey harvested in such a hands-on, natural way.
If you would like to receive the monthly newsletter from Beewhisperer360 drop your email address in the comments section.
I am thinking of this type of beekeeping. I have little experience with bees since I was a teenager. My grandfather raised them but I have gained interest at the age of 74. I would like more knfo ln these hives with less maintenance.
Hi Dennis, thanks for writing. Top bar hives require less maintenance but the up front costs are more expensive. As I wrote, if you use a langstroth beehive the boxes can become very heavy to lift when full of honey. Sometimes it takes two people to make it happen. I list a top bar hive on my resources page. Just click on the link and you can evaluate the equipment. If you like it you can buy it right there. Let me know if you have any other questions.
P.S. April is usually the best time to start beekeeping. I also have a page on where and how you get bees.
Best
Gordon
I have learnt so much here especially during harvesting the honey. I last time, I removed all the combs and the bees left the hive after 2 days. I was wondering why they left. I am wondering on how to get them back.
Hi Ita,
If they swarmed away you probably won’t get them back. When I pull frames with honey I temporarily install empty frames I their place. Then I replace the empty frames for the bees to clean.